Cloisonné Enamel

Cloisonné, Champlevé, and Cold Enamel: What Is the Difference?

Compare how metal strips or recesses make the cells, how glass or resin sets, and what a finished photo can tell you.

By BeenEast Editorial · Published · Reviewed

Two questions to ask about any piece

Cloisonné and champlevé describe how a maker forms the spaces for enamel. In cloisonné, added metal strips divide the surface into cells. In champlevé, the cells are recesses in the metal itself. Both can use glass enamel fused by heat. “Cold enamel” is a trade label for a fill or coating. It can refer to a resin that hardens by curing, and the label leaves the shape of the cells open.

Sources: V&A · A guide to metalworking techniques · CONIEX · ESMALTEX cold enamels

Cloisonné builds the walls above the base

On the unfinished vessel, dense scrolls and bands rise above the bare lower body. You can see where the pattern ends and the metal surface continues. A narrow strip stands on edge. Its side contains the fill, and its top can remain visible as a fine line between colors.

Unfinished copper vessel with raised wire scrolls and bands above a bare lower body.
The scrolls and narrow bands end above the bare rounded body.

The cross section below isolates two cells. The dark seams mark where added strips meet the base. They show the relationship between the parts. The exact attachment method depends on the workshop and object.

Sources: V&A · A guide to metalworking techniques

Cross section of two colored glass cells divided by metal strips that sit on a continuous base.
Original schematic. Three upright strips sit above the base and divide the two glass fills.

Champlevé sets the glass into the metal

Here the raised divider and the floor of each recess are part of one metal body. Cutting, etching, or casting can produce the recesses. Once glass enamel fills them and the surface is finished, the remaining metal can outline the colors much like a cloisonné partition does. A photo of the finished face may show that outline clearly. A process view or an object record can tell you how it was made.

Sources: V&A · A guide to metalworking techniques

Cross section of blue and green glass in two recesses of a single metal body.
Original schematic at the same scale. The central divider and the floors of the recesses belong to the same metal body.

A resin fill can use the same walls

The last cross section uses the same added walls as the cloisonné drawing. Only the fill has changed. In this example, a colored epoxy hardens by curing. Glass enamel hardens into a glass surface after fusing in a firing. CONIEX describes its ESMALTEX cold enamels as two-part epoxy resins. Other products may use the label differently, so ask for the material name and how it hardens.

Sources: CONIEX · ESMALTEX cold enamels · Guild of Enamellers · What is vitreous enamelling?

Cross section of two resin fills between added metal strips above a continuous base.
Original schematic at the same scale. The walls match the added-strip drawing. The dotted areas represent resin in this example.

What to check in a listing or class

Compare the wall and the fill
ExampleWhat forms the boundaryHow the fill sets
Cloisonné enamelAdded metal stripsGlass fuses in a firing
Champlevé enamelRecesses in the metal bodyGlass fuses in a firing
Wire with a resin fillAdded strips in this exampleResin hardens by curing

If a listing says “handwired enamel,” ask what was placed between the wires and how it hardened. A work-in-progress photo may answer where the wall came from. A maker’s description or materials sheet can answer what the colored fill is. In a class, a prepared base can give you practice placing color. Shaping the strips, firing glass, or examining a fired sample teaches a different part of the process. Ask which of those steps you will do yourself.

Continue reading

References

V&A · A guide to metalworking techniques

CONIEX · ESMALTEX cold enamels

Guild of Enamellers · What is vitreous enamelling?

Back to Cloisonné Enamel guides