Hand Dyeing

How to Get a Darker Blue with Indigo Dips

Compare one, two, and three indigo dips on matching cotton swatches, then choose a dip count from the washed, dry results.

By BeenEast Editorial · Published · Reviewed

Build the blue one dip at a time

To build a deeper indigo blue on cotton, dip the cloth, let both sides oxidize in the air, then repeat. To choose a dip count for your fabric and dye bath, stop three matching swatches after one, two, and three cycles and compare them after washing and drying.

Sources: Jacquard — Indigo Tie Dye Kit Quick Start · Brooklyn Botanic Garden — DIY Shibori with Indigo

In the vat, indigo is in a form that can dissolve in water. As the cloth meets air, oxygen changes the dye back into its insoluble blue form. Count one dip and its air exposure as one cycle. The blue you see at this point is still on wet cloth.

Sources: Brooklyn Botanic Garden — DIY Shibori with Indigo

Prepare three pieces from the same cotton

Cut three equal pieces from the same cotton you plan to use. Prepare them together, following your dye instructions, and leave them flat and unbound. A tight fold can limit where dye reaches the cloth and make one swatch look paler even at the same dip count.

Sources: Brooklyn Botanic Garden — DIY Shibori with Indigo

Set out three numbered spots on a tray for the wet cloth. Use the same prepared vat for all three. Keep the time per dip and the air exposure per round consistent, using the instructions for your kit or vat.

Sources: Jacquard — Indigo Tie Dye Kit Quick Start

Stop one swatch after each round

Dip all three swatches in the first round. Once they have had the full air exposure specified for your vat, retire swatch 1. Dip swatches 2 and 3 again, let both oxidize, and retire swatch 2. Give swatch 3 one final dip and air exposure.

Sources: Jacquard — Indigo Tie Dye Kit Quick Start

Lift the swatch slowly from the vat at A. At B, open it out and turn it so both faces meet the air; separate any parts that are folded against each other. Wear the gloves specified by your dye instructions. The two cloth shapes at B show opposite faces of the same swatch, not two different samples.

Sources: Jacquard — Indigo Tie Dye Kit Quick Start

A shows a swatch lifting out of the vat. B shows the two faces of the swatch, a flip arrow, and a clock. A dashed +1 arrow leads from the clock into the vat opening.
Original diagram. Lift at A, then open and flip the cloth at B. After the required air exposure, the dashed +1 arrow leads into the vat for another round. Swatches that have reached their count go to washing.

Give the swatch the full air exposure called for in your vat instructions, even if the cloth turns blue sooner. Jacquard’s quick start specifies 20 minutes for its kit. Follow the timing for your own vat.

Sources: Jacquard — Indigo Tie Dye Kit Quick Start

After oxidation, follow the dashed +1 arrow back into the vat if the swatch still needs another round. When it reaches its assigned count, move on to rinsing, washing, and drying. Finish all three the same way and keep their numbers with them.

Sources: Jacquard — Indigo Tie Dye Kit Quick Start

The next three photographs follow one wool sweater in Elizabeth and Debbie Sullivan’s tutorial. They show the first dip, the following air exposure, and removal after the second dip. This is a separate demonstration of the cycle, not the cotton test above; its timing and shades do not transfer to cotton.

Sources: Elizabeth and Debbie Sullivan — Indigo Dip Dye Tutorial (photos: Debbie Sullivan)

A cream knit sweater hangs from a clamped dowel with its lower section submerged in a blue tub.
First dip. The dowel holds the undyed section above the bath. Photo: Debbie Sullivan.

The first air exposure makes the change visible across the cloth. Keep the distinction between oxidation and drying: the fabric in this photograph is wet.

Sources: Elizabeth and Debbie Sullivan — Indigo Dip Dye Tutorial (photos: Debbie Sullivan)

The wet sweater rests over a rack; a green band below the fold meets a bluer area above.
After dip 1, during oxidation. Green and blue coexist in the wet knit. Photo: Debbie Sullivan.

On the second lift, the dyed area already carries blue from the earlier cycle. A later dip need not look as green as the first one.

Sources: Elizabeth and Debbie Sullivan — Indigo Dip Dye Tutorial (photos: Debbie Sullivan)

A hand lifts the dowel and wet blue sweater above the tub; the lowest edge remains dark and greenish.
After dip 2, as the sweater leaves the vat. This is still wet cloth. Photo: Debbie Sullivan.

Compare the dry cloth under one light

Lay the three dry swatches flat on the same background with their numbers visible. Compare the centers in the same light. If one looks patchy, check several areas before ranking it. Photograph all three together so you have a record of the shades under one set of lighting conditions.

The numbered comparison below is an independent cotton experiment by Lai and Chang, photographed after the recorded washing and drying procedure. Numbers 1–9 identify one to nine cycles.

Sources: Lai and Chang — Indigo Dyeing Experiment, Figure 2 (CC BY 4.0)

Nine numbered cotton samples in two rows, from pale blue at upper left to deep blue at lower right.
Samples 1–9 received one to nine cycles, respectively. The time per dip also increased from 2 to 6 minutes over the series, so the shades reflect a schedule that varied both factors. Adapted from Lai and Chang, Figure 2 (2021), CC BY 4.0. Rearranged in two rows and resized.

In Lai and Chang’s cotton series, the first few samples show a clearer change in shade than several neighbors at the dark end. To see what one more round does in your own vat, keep the time per dip and per air exposure the same for all swatches.

Sources: Lai and Chang — Indigo Dyeing Experiment, Figure 2 (CC BY 4.0) · Creative Commons Attribution 4.0

A separate workshop record by Sophia Naureen Ahmad shows the cloth after it was fully dried and ironed. The range of pale and darker pieces is easy to see, but this set mixes cotton and silk, and the dip counts are approximate. It shows why finished samples are useful records; it cannot establish a one-dip color increment.

Sources: Sophia Naureen Ahmad — Inside Indigo: dried workshop samples

Five cloth samples lie on a pale background, with pale blue squares beside darker blue-gray pieces.
Fully dried and ironed samples. Ahmad records 1–2 dips for the lighter pieces and up to 5–6 for the darker ones; individual counts are not mapped. Photo: Sophia Naureen Ahmad.

Record a starting point for the next piece

If two and three dips look equally close to your target, start with two on a fresh scrap. If three dips are still too light and each round made a visible difference, test a fourth cycle on another scrap.

If the two- and three-dip swatches are both too light and look nearly the same, pause before adding another dip. First, confirm both were washed the same way and are fully dry. Compare the same area of each under the same light.

Next, check the swatch labels and your notes. Confirm each swatch got the planned number of dips, the same time per dip, and the full air exposure on both sides after every dip.

Finally, check whether the vat is ready to use according to the instructions for your dye method. Once the vat is ready and the timing is consistent, repeat the two- and three-dip comparison on fresh scraps of the same cotton before dyeing the full piece.

Sources: Jacquard — Indigo Tie Dye Kit Quick Start

Keep the chosen swatch with the fabric, vat, dip count, time per dip and per air exposure, and finishing method. A vat can yield different shades over time. Catharine Ellis recorded a similar blue from two dips in May and five dips in the same vat the following February. Retest when you change the fabric, vat, or fold.

Sources: Catharine Ellis — The Life of an Indigo Vat

Continue reading

Reuse and citation

English PDF and Markdown contain the text; their photo links open the illustrated guide.

BeenEast Editorial. How to Get a Darker Blue with Indigo Dips. Version 1.0 (2026-11-13). https://community.beeneast.com/guides/indigo-dye-repeat-dips

The cotton exercise, Sullivan’s wool demonstration, Lai and Chang’s numbered cotton experiment, and Ahmad’s dried samples are separate examples. Photographs retain their original colors.

References

Jacquard — Indigo Tie Dye Kit Quick Start

Brooklyn Botanic Garden — DIY Shibori with Indigo

Lai and Chang — Indigo Dyeing Experiment, Figure 2 (CC BY 4.0)

Creative Commons Attribution 4.0

Catharine Ellis — The Life of an Indigo Vat

Elizabeth and Debbie Sullivan — Indigo Dip Dye Tutorial (photos: Debbie Sullivan)

Sophia Naureen Ahmad — Inside Indigo: dried workshop samples

Back to Hand Dyeing guides